понедельник, 25 января 2021 г.

XI. "Chartres" (History of the Western Catholic Church 1046-1309)

After centuries of domination by laypeople (872-1046), at the Synod of Sutri in 1046 the westerm Catholic church broke free and a new Pope was installed, Clement II. After a succession of similarly reforming popes, in 1073 the Benedictine monk, Hildebrand, part of the Cluny movement for monastic reform, became Pope Gregory VII. He continued the trend towards centralisation in the name of reform, declaring the pope as universal bishop and vicar of St Peter (Dictatus Papae, 1075) and purging the church of simony (church positions being bought) and sexual immorality among the clergy. Gregory VII's face-off with western Emperor Henry IV, temporarily led to the latter's humiliation, but eventually led to the Pope spending his final years in exile. The longstanding controversy over lay investiture was finally resolved at Worms in 1122, at which it was agreed that the secular power conferred only secular benefits on clerics, while spiritual power lay with the church. The height of papal power and centralisation came under Innocent III, who presided at the 1215 Council (Lateran IV), which proclaimed the Pope to have "plenitude of power"; all power, spiritual and also secular, allegedly derived from the Pope, the "Vicar of Christ". 

Meanwhile, from the time of Pope Urban II (1098), the Western Catholic Church sponsored Crusades, successive military campaigns to reclaim the Holy Sites of Christendom from Muslim control. In 1204 the Fourth Crusade led to the sacking of Eastern Orthodox Christian Constantinople and its occupation by the western powers, established a Western Catholic Patriarch. This act finalised the schism of 1054 between the western Catholic church of Rome and the eastern Orthodox Church in Constantinople. Crusades were also directed towards pagans (Northern Crusades) and heretics, such as the Cathars. Later Gregory IX set up the Inquisition (literally: "Interrogation") as means of combating heresy. An alternative, more irenic, non-coercive approach was adopted by preaching orders such as the Dominicans, and western missionaries to Muslims, such as Francis of Assisi and Raymond Lull (see also below).  

The Cistercian movement, founded in 1097, rekindled the reforming zeal of the earlier Cluny monastic reform movement begun in 910. The most famous Cistercian monk was Bernard of Clairvaux (1090-1153), a monk, mystic, preacher and Bible scholar. Another centre of Christian mysticism at the time was the Abbey of St Victor.   

A new impetus in the western church came from various grass-roots movements aiming to get back to the "apostolic life" of the New Testament: simplicity, mission and poverty. An early example were the Poor of Lyons, began by Valdo (hence "Waldensians") from around 1173. This movement was rejected by the church and became a proto-Protestant church, which in the 16th century joined the Reformation. However, later similar movements, such as those began by Francis of Assisi and Dominic Guzman, were given papal blessing and became new mendicant monastic orders (Franciscans and Dominicans, respectively). Other mendicant orders formed somewhat later included the Carmelites (1247). 

The 13th century was also a time of architectural and academic achievement. The Cathedral of Saint Denis, Paris, completed in 1144, became a model for what was later referred to as 'Gothic' style of church architecture ("opus Francigenum"), symbolising the medieval dominance of Christianity and its striving heavenwards. Arguably one of the greatest examples of Gothic architecture is the cathedral at Chartres (picture). At the recently founded universities, following earlier thinkers such as Anselm (1033-1109), Albert the Great, Thomas Aquinas and other scholastics systematised Christian thinking, inspired by ancient Greek philosopher Aristotle. A motto of scholasticism was "faith seeking understanding".  

After a long period of decline following the death of Innocent III in 1216, under Pope Boniface VIII the emerging Kingdom of France, under Philip the Fair, overcame, leading to the election in 1305 of French Pope Clement V, who never stepped foot in Rome and eventually set up his residence in Avignon from 1309 - the start of the so-called Babylonian captivity of the western church (1309-1377). 

четверг, 14 января 2021 г.

Церковь и общество (Г. Флоровский)

"The early church was not just a voluntary association for "religious" purposes. It was rather the New Society, even the New Humanity, a polis or politeuma, the true City of God, in the process of construction. And each local community was fully aware of its membership in an inclusive and universal whole. The church was conceived as an independent and self-supporting social order, as a new social dimension, a peculiar systema patridos, as Origen put it. Early Christians felt themselves, in the last resort, quite outside of the existing social order, simply because for them the church itself was an "order," an extra-territorial "colony of Heaven" on earth (Phil. 3:20, Moffatt's translation). Nor was this attitude fully abandoned even later when the empire, as it were, came to terms with the church."

(Georges Florovsky, Christianity and Culture vol 2, p132) 

"Ранняя Церковь не была просто добровольным объединением для «религиозных» целей. Она была новым обществом, даже новым человечеством, polis или роlitеuma, истинным Градом Божиим в процессе созидания. И каждая местная община вполне сознавала себя членом всеобъемлющего и универсального целого. Церковь понималась как независимый и самодовлеющий социальный строй, как новое социальное измерение, особая Systema patriados, как сказал Ориген. Первые христиане ощущали себя в конечном счете совершенно вне существовавшего социального порядка, просто потому, что для них сама Церковь являлась «порядком», своего рода экстратерриториальной «колонией Неба» на земле (Фил.3:20). От этого положения не вполне отказались даже и позже, когда империя как бы пришла к соглашению с Церковью. 

(протоиерей Георгий Флоровский, https://azbyka.ru/otechnik/Georgij_Florovskij/bogoslovskie-stati-o-tserkvi/)   

среда, 13 января 2021 г.

Исполнение великой симфонии (о проповеди Евангелия)

"No two violinists will play a symphony exactly the same, but the brilliance and genius of the composer will be set forth by the faithful artist. This is the task of the gospel proclaimer: to process and package the truth of the evangel for listeners of our time." (David Larsen)

"Два скрипача не исполнят симфонию одинаково, но верный артист передаст мастерство и гениальность композитора. Вот задача того, кто провозглашает Евангелие: обработать и предподнести истину Евангелия для слушателей нашего времени." (Дэвид Ларсен) 

понедельник, 4 января 2021 г.

What would I preach on this coming Sunday? (First Sunday after Epiphany)

I have been pondering what I might preach on this coming Sunday, 10 January 2021. (I hope to take up a role as minister of a local church later in the year.) 

Let me first lay out options if I were preaching following the church calendar (lectionary). In terms of the church calendar, which seeks to replicate the events of Christ's life in the Scripture reading and preaching of the church, we find ourselves in the season of Epiphany, after the birth of Christ but before the start of his public ministry. Various options for preaching present themselves:
  • The Murder of the Innocents (Matthew 2:13ff) trad. 28 December
  • The Circumcision of Christ (Luke 2:21 cf. Galatians 4) trad. 1 January
  • The Baptist of Christ (Matthew 3/Mark 1/Luke 3/John 1) trad. the first Sunday after Epiphany (10 January this year) 
  • Christ's genealogy in the gospel of Luke (Luke 3:23-38), emphasising his connection with the whole human race
  • The presentation of Christ (Luke 2:22ff) trad. 2 February
  • Christ in the Temple (Luke 2:41-52), which speaks both of His human nature and of his awareness of His divine Sonship (2:49) 
At this time it would seem right to focus on the first thirty plus years of the Lord's earthly life, leading up to his baptism in the Jordan. A related passage might be Romans 5:12-21 which speaks of Christ as the Other Adam, or the concept of recapitulation, developed theologically by Irenaeus of Lyon, as suggested by Ephesians 1:10. Here is a quotation from Irenaeus' writings:

"For this reason, He also passed through every stage of life, restoring fellowship with God to all [stages of life]... God recapitulated in himself the ancient formation of man, so that he might kill sin, deprive death of its power, and impart life to man." (Irenaeus, Against Heresies 3:6,12) 

There is, of course, no compulsion to follow the church calendar and there may be other more pressing subjects relevant for God's people on a given Sunday. A Scripture which has been relevant recently is 2 Corinthians 2:14 (in particular the words "in every place"). 

суббота, 2 января 2021 г.

Scythia - the revolving door into Europe

Before the days of planes and political asylum, the most common way into Europe was via an area known historically as Scythia - the Danube Basin (Scythia Minor) and the Pontic-Caspian steppe (Scythia Major).  

As I have been writing up a masters thesis on the missionary work from Constantinople, again and again this area and this phenomenon has been relevant. I have identified several phases of the occupation/settlement of these areas. As I am able to access more data and scholarship, I hope to expand the information below with authoritative maps. 

1. Goths and Huns (from 376) 

2. Gepids and Cutrigurs, Utrigurs and Bulgars (from 453) 

3. Slavs and Avars (from 557) 

4. Bulgars/Bulgarians and Khazars; the so-called Pax Chazarica (from 630) 

5. Pechenegs and Cumans (from 10th century) 

There were earlier and later phases of this phenomenon (i.e. pre-IV century and post-XI century). 

In many cases the peoples dominant in this area either went on to migrate into Europe, or lost their ethnic identity vis-a-vis newly dominant peoples. A primary example of the latter would be the Avars who, following their unsuccessful siege of Constantinople, were absorbed by their Slavic neighbours and in the 'reconquest' of the Balkans by Constantinople.